Every web designer has had this moment: you're browsing the internet, you land on some local business's website, and you physically wince. The layout is broken on your phone. There's a "Not Secure" warning. The hero image is a blurry stock photo of a handshake. And somewhere in the footer, it says "Copyright 2018."

That wince is actually a business opportunity. But finding these sites efficiently, qualifying them, and turning the discovery into a pitch that doesn't feel sleazy? That's where most people get stuck. Let me walk through the whole process.

What Actually Makes a Website "Bad"

Before you go hunting, you need specific criteria. "It looks old" isn't enough. You need measurable problems you can point to in your outreach. Here's what I check:

Any two of these together signals a serious redesign candidate. Three or more and you're looking at a business that's actively losing customers to competitors with better sites.

Finding Them Manually

The most straightforward method: open Google Maps, search for a business type in a city, and start clicking through websites. "Plumber Portland OR" gives you 200+ results. Click through ten of their websites and I guarantee you'll find at least three that make you cringe.

What to do with each one:

  1. Load the website on your phone. Note how it looks and how long it takes.
  2. Check the URL bar for "Not Secure" (no SSL).
  3. Look at the footer for the copyright year.
  4. Check if the design looks like it was built in the last 3 years.
  5. Note the business name, website, and phone number.

This works, but it's slow. You're realistically evaluating 10-15 businesses per hour. For initial practice and learning what to look for, it's great. For building a pipeline, you'll want to speed things up.

Finding Them at Scale

Automated scoring tools turn a half-day manual process into a 15-minute task. LeadsByLocation's scoring tool checks all six signals I mentioned above in about 10 seconds per site. Paste a URL, get a score out of 100. Anything below 50 means multiple problems.

For bulk prospecting, the search feature is where it gets really efficient. Search a city and business type, and every result comes back pre-scored. Sort by score, and the worst websites float to the top. That's your prospect list, built in minutes instead of hours.

Google PageSpeed Insights is another option for one-off checks. It gives deep technical detail on performance, but you're doing one site at a time, and it doesn't check for SSL, analytics, or schema.

The "No Website" vs. "Bad Website" Distinction

This tripped me up early on. I assumed businesses with no website at all were the hottest prospects. "You don't even have a website! Let me build you one!" Turns out, those are usually the hardest to sell.

A business with no website has survived without one. They're getting referrals, or they rely entirely on their Google Business Profile, or they just don't think a website matters. Convincing them otherwise is an uphill battle.

A business with a bad website is a completely different conversation. They already decided a website matters. They already spent money on one. They already understand the concept. Their current site just isn't doing the job, and deep down, most of them know it. You're not selling them on the idea of a website. You're selling them on a better one. That's a much easier pitch.

The one exception: businesses with no website but 50+ Google reviews. They're clearly successful and busy. They just never got around to building a site. These can be great prospects because they have budget and they're already visible online. The pitch here is: "You're getting customers despite not having a website. Imagine what would happen if you did."

Turning Your Findings Into a Pitch

Here's where most web designers blow it. They find a bad website and send something like: "Hi, I noticed your website could use some improvements. I'm a web designer and I'd love to help." That email gets deleted immediately. It's vague and it's presumptuous.

What works is leading with specific, factual observations:

"Hi Sarah, I came across Thompson Family Dental while researching dental practices in Phoenix. I noticed a few things about your website: it's showing a 'Not Secure' warning in Chrome, it takes about 5 seconds to load on mobile, and it doesn't appear to have any structured data, which means Google can't show your star ratings in search results. Your practice has 127 five-star reviews. Those should be showing up when people search for dentists."

See the difference? Every sentence is a fact, not an opinion. You're not saying "your website is bad." You're pointing out specific, verifiable issues and connecting them to business impact. That's helpful, not salesy.

Real Examples of What to Look For

Here are the patterns I see over and over when evaluating small business sites:

Make It a Weekly Practice

The agencies that consistently land redesign clients aren't doing this once and stopping. They have a weekly routine: search a new city or business type, score the websites, identify the worst 15-20, and send personalized outreach based on what they found.

Over time, you develop an eye for it. You'll start noticing bad websites everywhere, at the restaurant you ate at last night, on the business card someone handed you, on the van parked in your neighbor's driveway. Every one of those is a potential client. The ones who already know their site is bad and just haven't found the right person to fix it? Those are the easiest deals you'll ever close.

Related reading